Best Nutrafol Alternatives for Women
What are the best Nutrafol alternatives for women, and are any cheaper?
Reviewed by Taylor Anderson, RN
Aesthetic Registered Nurse
Taylor Anderson is an aesthetic registered nurse and a reviewer for Hot or Nothing.
Updated November 17, 2026
Quick answer
For thinning hair, the best Nutrafol alternatives are Viviscal, at $36 a month on subscription at viviscal.com vs $79 at nutrafol.com (checked November 2026), and minoxidil, as Women's Rogaine 5% foam or low-dose pills. Viviscal is the cheaper supplement swap. Minoxidil is the stronger choice when your part is widening and hair loss runs in your family.
Thinning hair or a wider part? See which hair loss treatment fits you.
See My PlanIn this guide
Key takeaways
- Viviscal costs $36 a month on a monthly subscription at viviscal.com, compared with $79 for Nutrafol at nutrafol.com, which is $43 less a month (both checked November 2026).
- Nutrafol contains saw palmetto, which a dermatology review calls unsafe in pregnancy, and Viviscal contains a small amount of biotin, so tell your clinical team you take it before bloodwork.
- If your part is widening and hair loss runs in your family, minoxidil is the alternative to try, either as Women's Rogaine 5% foam, which is labeled to regrow hair on top of the scalp, or as low-dose pills that our clinical team can prescribe if they fit your health history.
- You do not have to give up your supplement to start minoxidil, because a dermatology review says supplements likely work best when added to treatments such as topical minoxidil.
For thinning hair, the best Nutrafol alternatives are Viviscal, which costs $36 a month on subscription vs Nutrafol's $79 (checked November 2026), and minoxidil: Women's Rogaine 5% foam, labeled to regrow hair on top of the scalp, or low-dose pills. Viviscal is the cheaper supplement swap. Minoxidil is the stronger choice when your part is widening and hair loss runs in your family. You can see every hair treatment we offer on our hair page.
What are the best alternatives to Nutrafol for women?
The best alternatives are Viviscal if you want another supplement, and Women's Rogaine 5% foam or low-dose oral minoxidil if you want a drug made to regrow hair. We judged each option three ways: whether it has a published trial in women (and that trial's size and length), what the seller charges on its own site in November 2026, and whether it has an FDA drug label for hair regrowth.
| Option | What it is | Key ingredients or drug | Evidence | Monthly price (seller, month checked) | How you take it | Time to results | Main side effects | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nutrafol Women (the price to beat) | Supplement | Saw palmetto, ashwagandha, vitamin E, marine collagen, hyaluronic acid and kelp, plus vitamins and minerals (review) | 6-month placebo-controlled trial of 40 women who noticed their own thinning (26 took Nutrafol Women, 14 took a placebo). The Nutrafol group grew more terminal hairs (thick, full-length) and vellus hairs (fine, short) than the placebo group at day 90 and day 180. | nutrafol.com, November 2026: $88 one-time, $79 a month on a monthly subscription, $224 per 3-month delivery (about $75 a month), $422 per 6-month delivery (about $70 a month). New subscribers get 25% off the first order. | By mouth, as the label directs | Gains showed at day 90 and day 180 in the trial | No adverse events reported in the trial. Contains saw palmetto, which a dermatology review calls unsafe in pregnancy. | Women with self-noticed thinning who want a supplement and are not pregnant |
| Viviscal Hair Growth Supplement | Supplement | Shark and mollusc powder, with no drugs or hormones; about 100 to 240 mcg of biotin (review) | 90-day placebo-controlled trial of Viviscal Extra Strength in 60 women who noticed their own thinning, taken twice daily. Terminal hairs in the measured scalp area rose from 178.3 to 235.8 on Viviscal and from 178.2 to 180.9 on placebo. Shed hairs per wash fell from 27.1 to 16.5. | viviscal.com, November 2026: single box $40 plus $6.95 shipping, $36 a month on a monthly subscription, $96 per 3 months (about $32 a month), $180 per 6 months (about $30 a month). Free shipping on subscriptions. | By mouth, twice daily in the trial | Gains showed at 90 days in the trial | No adverse events reported in the trial | Women with self-noticed thinning who want a supplement for less |
| Women's Rogaine 5% foam | Over-the-counter drug sold under an FDA new drug application | Minoxidil 5% | FDA drug label. Purpose: "hair regrowth treatment for women." Use: "to regrow hair on the top of the scalp." | Depends on the seller; compare options in our minoxidil guide. One 60 g can is a two-month supply. | Half a capful on the scalp once a day | Results may show at 3 months. Some women need at least 6 months. | The label says to stop and ask a doctor if you get unwanted facial hair, scalp irritation, a rapid heartbeat or swollen hands or feet. | Women with a family history of hair loss who are thinning on top of the scalp |
| Low-dose oral minoxidil | Prescription pill | Minoxidil, 2.5 mg a day or less in the review | Mayo Clinic review of 25 women with pattern hair loss (average age 61) who took it for an average of 6.2 months. 9 of the 25 regrew hair. | Depends on your prescription | One pill by mouth, at the dose prescribed | Women in the review took it for an average of 6.2 months | 4 of 25 grew facial hair and kept taking it. 1 got leg swelling and stopped. Blood pressure barely changed. | Women with pattern hair loss who find a daily foam hard to stick with |
Prices checked November 2026.
Is Viviscal cheaper than Nutrafol, and is it as good?
Yes, Viviscal is cheaper. On a monthly subscription it costs $36 at viviscal.com vs $79 at nutrafol.com, which is $43 less a month and $516 less a year. On the 6-month plans it is $180 (viviscal.com) vs $422 (nutrafol.com), or $242 less every six months (both checked November 2026 on the sellers' own sites).
No trial has compared the two head to head, so neither is proven better. Each beat a placebo in its own small trial of women with self-noticed thinning: 60 women for 90 days for Viviscal, 40 women for 6 months for Nutrafol.
A dermatology review of hair supplements, including both brands, found they help hair grow "to a modest degree." Set your expectations from that, not from the ads.
Two practical differences matter. Nutrafol contains saw palmetto, which the review calls unsafe in pregnancy. Viviscal contains about 100 to 240 micrograms of biotin, compared with 5,000 in most biotin supplements, so it may have a smaller effect on lab tests. Tell your clinical team you take it before bloodwork either way. For more supplements side by side, see our guide to the best hair supplements for women.
Should you try minoxidil instead of a hair supplement?
If your part is widening and hair loss runs in your family, minoxidil is the alternative to try. The Viviscal trial left out women diagnosed with pattern hair loss, patchy loss or heavy shedding after illness or stress (called telogen effluvium). Its results apply to milder thinning that women noticed themselves.
The Women's Rogaine foam label describes the woman it is for. It tells you not to use it if you have no family history of hair loss, if your loss is sudden or patchy, if it is tied to childbirth, or if you do not know the reason. You have to keep using it to keep the regrowth, or hair loss starts again. The label also says it may be harmful if you are pregnant or breastfeeding.
Pills are the other route if a daily foam is a hassle. In the Mayo review, 10 of the 25 women had stopped topical minoxidil because of scalp side effects or trouble sticking with it, then moved to low-dose pills.
Hot or Nothing is a third route. Our clinical team can prescribe minoxidil if it fits your goal and your health history. If your thinning started around perimenopause, our guide to hair loss treatments for women over 40 covers what else can help.
Can you use minoxidil and keep taking Nutrafol or Viviscal?
Yes. The dermatology review says supplements likely give the best results when added to treatments such as topical minoxidil, not used in place of them.
If you love your supplement, you do not have to give it up to start minoxidil. If budget is the issue, it makes more sense to put your money into minoxidil and switch to the cheaper supplement than to pay Nutrafol's full price (see the table) for a supplement alone. Tell your clinical team everything you take.
What women share
We read 251 threads from r/FemaleHairLoss and r/Hairloss posted from October 2025 to October 2026. 141 of 251 named a treatment. Of those 141, 76 mentioned topical minoxidil, 68 mentioned oral minoxidil, 60 mentioned spironolactone and 7 mentioned PRP. Topical minoxidil came up most, in more than half of the threads that named a treatment.
Women weigh the body hair side effect openly. In one thread, a woman wrote, "I worry about going on minoxidil because I have a lot of body hair as it is." Another replied: "even if I turn into a little monkey as long as I have hair on my head I don't care and will save for laser."
The woman who started that thread said that after 1.5 years on oral minoxidil and spironolactone, "I feel better mentally," and that she can now straighten her hair without losing much volume.
If your part is getting wider and you want more than a supplement can offer, take the quiz and choose the hair goal. Your clinical team will see whether minoxidil fits your thinning and your health history. You can also compare every option on our hair page.
Ready to make a move?
Answer three questions to see the treatment options that fit your goals.
See My PlanFAQ
Does Viviscal have biotin in it?
Yes, Viviscal contains about 100 to 240 micrograms of biotin, according to a dermatology review of hair supplements. That is far less than the 5,000 micrograms in most biotin supplements, so it may have a smaller effect on lab tests. Tell your clinical team you take it before bloodwork.
How long does Viviscal take to work?
In the Viviscal Extra Strength trial, gains showed at 90 days. In that trial, 60 women who noticed their own thinning took it or a placebo twice daily, and thick, full-length hairs in the measured scalp area rose from 178.3 to 235.8 on Viviscal vs 178.2 to 180.9 on placebo. Shed hairs per wash also fell from 27.1 to 16.5 on Viviscal.
Does Nutrafol have a money-back guarantee?
Yes, Nutrafol offers a money-back guarantee on subscriptions. According to nutrafol.com, its Real Growth Guarantee means you get your money back if you do not see results within 6 months. A monthly subscription costs $79 a month on nutrafol.com.
Is oral minoxidil safe for women?
In a Mayo Clinic review of 25 women taking low-dose oral minoxidil, the side effects were facial hair in 4 women, who kept taking it, and leg swelling in 1 woman, who stopped. Blood pressure barely changed. The women had pattern hair loss, were 61 on average, took 2.5 mg a day or less and stayed on it for an average of 6.2 months. It is a prescription pill, so your clinical team checks whether it fits your health history.
Keep reading
Sources (5)
- A Six-Month, Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Study Evaluating the Safety and Efficacy of a Nutraceutical Supplement for Promoting Hair Growth in Women With Self-Perceived Thinning Hair - PubMed · pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov · captured November 16, 2026
- Nutraceuticals for Androgenetic Alopecia - PMC · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov · captured November 16, 2026
- A 3-Month, Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Study Evaluating the Ability of an Extra-Strength Marine Protein Supplement to Promote Hair Growth and Decrease Shedding in Women with Self-Perceived Thinning Hair - PMC · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov · captured November 16, 2026
- Is Nutrafol Worth It? A Look at Cost, Results, and Value · nutrafol.com · captured November 16, 2026
- Exclusive Offers & Discounts Details | Viviscal · viviscal.com · captured November 16, 2026
